WikiPatterns

Patterns for successful wiki use

User Tools

Site Tools


registration_required

Registration Required

Classification
TypeAnti-Pattern
FocusAdoption

This pattern refers to the common practice of requiring users to register to edit wiki pages, yet not tying the registration to any meaningful authenticator—just to a password. The result is a wiki that is vulnerable to vandalism and wiki spam, is vulnerable to identity spoofing and other things, yet requires users to create a password-protected identity for their first edit and to log on for subsequent edits.

How do I notice it?

  • You have trouble with wiki spammers, in spite of registration.
  • You have someone registering slight variants of some trusted user's account for edits (“Barton C Massey” vs “Bart Massey”).
  • You don't get many drive-by contributions.

How do I fix it?

One way is to adopt an Open-Edit policy, allowing anybody to edit the wiki without registering, and employing alternative effective measures to combat spam.

Another is to use a Clean Permissions scheme, such as Permission Granted or Community Write

Another is to provide an incentive for registering, such as a personal profile space, which gives a person space on the wiki to tell about her/himself, and allows them more flexibility in using the wiki than just contributing to the community space.

Further Reading

registration_required.txt · Last modified: 2018/11/28 16:07 by splitbrain